The mushroom killer was obsessed with true crime. Now true crime fans are obsessed with her

Erin Patterson was once a well-known member of an online true crime community, where she earned a reputation as a 'super sleuth' for her research skills and interest in famous criminal cases. However, her life changed dramatically when she became the focus of a real-life crime story. Two years ago, Erin hosted a lunch at her home in rural Victoria, Australia, serving beef Wellington to her family. Tragically, three people died and another became seriously ill after eating the meal, which was later found to contain poisonous mushrooms. This shocking event turned Erin from a crime enthusiast into the main suspect in a high-profile murder case.

The trial took place in Morwell, a small town that suddenly became the center of national and international attention. Journalists from around the world crowded into the tiny courtroom, and people lined up outside every day, some arriving early in the morning with chairs and sleeping bags to secure a spot. The trial lasted 11 weeks and included testimony from over 50 witnesses. Erin’s past as a true crime fan became a topic of discussion, with people online and in the media analyzing every detail of her life and behavior. Social media was flooded with memes, theories, and even fake restaurant listings at her home address.

Public opinion was sharply divided. Some people were convinced of Erin’s guilt, pointing to her lies and her calm demeanor as evidence. Others, like true crime fan Tammy Egglestone, questioned whether the case was as clear-cut as it seemed, arguing that many people were making judgments without knowing all the facts. The secrecy surrounding the jury’s decision only fueled more speculation and debate.

The case has inspired a wave of media coverage, including TV specials, podcasts, documentaries, and books. Experts say that part of the fascination comes from the fact that the accused is a woman, which challenges traditional ideas about gender and crime. The story also reminds many people of other famous Australian cases, such as the Lindy Chamberlain trial, where a woman was wrongly convicted of murder.

While the public remains captivated by the drama, some people in the local community feel that the victims have been forgotten amid all the attention. Local leaders have expressed frustration that the case has brought unwanted publicity and overshadowed the grief of those who lost loved ones. Despite the verdict, the story of Erin Patterson continues to spark debate and curiosity, showing how true crime can capture the imagination of people far beyond the courtroom.