Critics are mixed over Sabrina Carpenter's album

Sabrina Carpenter, a well-known pop star and actress, has recently released her sixth album titled Short n' Sweet. At just 25 years old, she has already made a significant impact in the music industry, especially with her hit single Espresso, which has propelled her to new heights of fame. Critics have had varied reactions to her latest work, with some praising it as 'smart pop underneath the froth,' while others have been less kind, claiming it has 'no ideas, no integrity and no identity. ' This range of opinions highlights the differing tastes among music listeners. In a four-star review, one critic noted that while Short n' Sweet may not reach the exhilarating heights of Espresso, it still showcases Carpenter's unique style. The reviewer pointed out that most of the songs are around three minutes long, allowing Carpenter to explore various emotions such as intense love, dreamy sadness, and even vengeful anger. They likened her to a modern-day Dolly Parton, particularly in tracks like Coincidence and Slim Pickins, suggesting that beneath the fun and catchy surface, Carpenter is a serious artist with staying power. Another four-star review emphasized the album's ability to blend different genres, including TikTok pop, yacht rock, country, and R&B, without losing its identity. The critic highlighted songs like Taste and Coincidence, describing them as delightful and full of energy. However, not all reviews were positive. Some critics felt that the album lacked boldness and depth. One reviewer remarked that while the album is bright and cheerful, it does not deliver the same punch as her lead singles. They noted that many of the songs felt lightweight and derivative, lacking the originality that made Espresso such a standout hit. Another critic gave the album a score of seven out of ten, praising Carpenter for writing from the heart. They appreciated her honesty and emotional expression, stating that the album captures the thoughts and feelings of a 25-year-old woman navigating relationships. However, they also mentioned that Short n' Sweet is not as addictive as her previous work and may take time to resonate with listeners. In contrast, a more critical review awarded the album only two stars, calling it 'entirely forgettable. ' The reviewer argued that while Carpenter has a captivating aesthetic, the music itself lacks substance and innovative ideas. They expressed concern that her image as a 'sexy baby' might overshadow her musical talent. In conclusion, Sabrina Carpenter's Short n' Sweet has sparked a range of opinions among critics and fans alike. While some celebrate her growth as an artist and the catchy nature of her songs, others feel that the album does not quite live up to the high expectations set by her earlier hits.