Valentino的AI手袋廣告因詭異畫面引發強烈反彈

Valentino, a well-known Italian luxury fashion house, has recently faced criticism for its latest advertising campaign promoting the DeVain handbag. The campaign, which was shared on Instagram, featured visuals created using artificial intelligence, or AI. In the ad, a black, embroidered version of the DeVain bag is shown in front of a crowd, but the people’s faces and bodies are blurred and merged together, creating a surreal and somewhat unsettling effect. Many fans and followers of the brand expressed their disappointment with the ad, calling it 'disturbing,' 'sloppy,' and 'sad. ' Valentino described the campaign as a 'digital creative project' and collaborated with digital artists to produce the AI-generated visuals. The video included a label indicating it was made with AI. Throughout the ad, viewers see models emerging from a gold handbag, and at one point, the brand’s logo morphs into people’s arms, which then swirl together with other bodies. The overall effect was described by some as 'weird' and 'embarrassing. ' Hundreds of comments on Valentino’s Instagram post criticized the use of AI, with many saying it felt 'cheap' and 'lazy. ' One user commented that advertising campaigns should highlight talented creatives, and using AI instead was disappointing for a couture fashion house. Others urged the marketing team to 'read the room,' suggesting that the campaign did not match what people expect from a luxury brand. Dr Rebecca Swift, a senior vice president at Getty Images, noted that the negative reaction shows many people see AI-generated content as less valuable than work created by humans. She explained that while people might enjoy AI for personal use, they expect more from high-end brands, and even being transparent about using AI was not enough to win over the audience. The use of AI in Valentino’s campaign comes at a time when other fashion brands are also experimenting with generative AI tools. These tools can create images and videos quickly, helping companies save on production and promotion costs. Some see this as a way to explore new creative possibilities and improve processes like design and manufacturing. However, there are concerns that relying too much on AI could lead to fewer jobs for human workers and lower the quality of fashion products. Anne-Liese Prem, who leads cultural insights at a creative digital agency, said that the main issue is not the technology itself but what people think it replaces. She explained that when AI becomes part of a brand’s visual identity, people worry that efficiency is being chosen over artistry. Even if the campaign is creative, audiences may see it as a cost-saving measure rather than true innovation. Other brands, such as H&M and Guess, have also faced criticism for using AI in their advertising, with concerns about the impact on human models, photographers, and makeup artists. Ms Prem pointed out that while AI offers new creative opportunities, it also carries risks. Without a strong emotional idea behind it, AI-generated content can make luxury products feel less human, especially at a time when people value human presence more than ever. Valentino’s experience highlights the ongoing debate in the fashion industry about the role of AI. While some appreciate the new possibilities, many believe that luxury brands should continue to rely on human creativity and craftsmanship. As technology continues to evolve, the fashion world will need to find a balance between innovation and tradition to meet the expectations of their audience.